News & Updates

Minnesota’s Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS)—sometimes called a Renewable Energy Standard (RES)—was last updated in 2007. Most utilities have met it ahead of schedule. All but twelve states have some sort of RPS, twenty-nine of which are mandatory. Is it time for an update in Minnesota? What’s feasible?

The details and progress

In 2007 lawmakers codified a mandate out of what had been a voluntary set of goals to develop “a framework for the state of Minnesota to transition to a renewable energy economy that ends Minnesota’s contribution to greenhouse gases from burning fossil fuels within the next few decades.” From that moment onward, it has been “the energy policy of the state of Minnesota that: […] 25 percent of the total energy used in the state be derived from renewable energy resources by the year 2025.”

The RPS applies different schedules to the state’s utilities. Xcel Energy, the footprint of which covers most of the Twin Cities Metro, faces a steeper schedule; the bill treats Minnesota utilities that use nuclear power—Xcel is the only such utility—differently than the other utilities, whether they be investor-owned or cooperatives. The statute requires that the MN Department of Energy Resources, a division of the Department of Commerce, manage utility compliance with the standard on a bi-annual basis. The latest of these, issued in January, 2017, confirms that all utilities subject to the RPS had met goals applicable to December 31, 2015.

A recent report suggests that Minnesota’s utilities may be ahead of schedule, with statewide numbers at 25% renewable generation, which is above average compared to the rest of the nation. Climate hawks still have reasons to despair, however, as carbon emissions are slightly higher than the national average.* Power sector emissions nonetheless fell 27% from 2005 to 2017. The discrepancy between relatively high rates of renewable generation and worse-than-average carbon emissions likely stems from the state’s low reliance on natural gas (12% vs. 32% nationwide), which has replaced higher-carbon coal generation elsewhere. At 23%, nuclear power in Minnesota stands at slightly above the nationwide average.

The state, as you might expect, has added several gigawatts (GW) of renewable capacity since the RPS mandate in 2007. Note that in the energy world, capacity is what it sounds like, as is generation; while the RPS measures generation, new capacity was needed to meet it. Capacity is measured in magnitudes of watts (W, kW, MW, GW, TW), and generation in magnitudes of watt-hours (Wh, kWh, MWh, etc.). Wind turbines comprised much of that new generation, until 2017, when solar—with a surge in community solar development—led the way.

Source: Bloomberg New Energy Finance, “State energy factsheet: Minnesota,” March 1, 2018.

So far, our discussion has omitted the solar mandate of 2013, which requires that all public utilities in the state meet 1.5% of all generation with solar photovoltaic (PV) facilities by 2020, 10% of which must be smaller systems under 20 kW in capacity. The 1.5% solar carve out comes in addition to the RPS shown in the charts above. For reference, know that the carve out only stretches the state slightly above the current national average of 1.2% of PV generation.

Some reading this piece may wonder about the cost of the Minnesota RPS on utility ratepayers. Worry not! Even as of 2014, when renewables cost more than today, Minnesota Power and Otter Tail Power customers experienced a decrease in costs as a result of the RPS, while Xcel customers felt only a slight increase. More recent data reflects the falling cost curves of renewables globally: new hydro costs about 5¢/kWh on average; onshore wind, about 6¢/kWh; utility-scale solar, 10¢/kWh. These prices easily compete with fossil fuel-derived electricity, which can vary from 5¢/kWh to 17¢/kWh.

Moreover, price does not reflect value. The periods where electricity demand is highest—hot, sunny summer afternoons—and therefore, the marginal cost of electricity is highest, often coincide with peak renewable production, especially solar. Witness the stunning solar victory in 2014, when the Aurora project beat out natural gas on price alone for peaking power.

What’s next?

A recent North Star article discussed a Minneapolis proposal to power city assets with 100% renewable energy—an aggressive RPS in miniature (Minne-ature? Apologies.). Accounting for enough renewable energy to power a medium-sized city government’s assets is complicated, but feasible.

What about the rest of the state? Or the country? Some, like Prof. Mark Jacobson of Stanford, have proposed that the entire globe could rely on 100% renewable electricity—and everything else!—by 2050. Such a global system would require massive investments in transmission, management software, electric vehicles, and hydrogen-powered aircraft, in addition to new renewable capacity. Others have challenged Mr. Jacobson’s methods, but still concluded that massive decarbonization of the electric grid, to 80% renewable, is feasible within a generation, pardon the pun.

With the state’s utilities on track to meet Minnesota’s RPS on schedule and on the cheap, perhaps it’s time to do more.

____________________________________________________________

* Minnesota average .48 tCO2/MWh vs. nationwide average .45 tCO2/MWh (tons carbon dioxide per megawatt-hour).

Big Debt, Big Deal

Minnesota is living under a $27 billion mountain of student loan debt.1 A student graduating in Minnesota today has an average of $31,000 in debt.2 Whether we realize it or not, it is affecting both individuals and the broader community. The challenge of student loan...

Minnesota Business Tax Rate Equals U.S. Average

Business groups—including the Minnesota Business Partnership and Minnesota Chamber of Commerce—actively cultivate the notion that business taxes in the Gopher State are high relative to the rest of the nation. However, total state and local business taxes as a share...

Ensure Respect for Minimum Wage Laws

(Note: This article is co-authored with Laura Huizar, a staff attorney at the National Employment Law Project in Washington, D.C.) A few weeks ago, the St. Paul City Council introduced a draft ordinance that would raise the city’s minimum wage to $15 an hour. That’s a...

Caring in Central Minnesota

Minnesota is getting older every day.1 The aging of our population is increasing demand for home health and personal care workers. We also continue to have population growth through both immigration and natural growth. To fill the needs of our changing population we...

Gas Tax Buys One-Third Less Today Than in 2000

The single largest source of funding for Minnesota’s transportation system comes from the state gas tax. However, the purchasing power of that tax has dropped by over one-third over the course of the century, leaving funding for state roads and bridges in a precarious...

State Aids: The Shrinking Slice of the City Revenue Pie

City property taxes have increased significantly in recent decades. Even after adjusting for inflation and population growth, the property taxes collected by Minnesota cities have increased by 48% from 1990 to 2018. However, real (i.e., inflation-adjusted) per capita...

Government Growth in Context

Shocking claims of growth in government abound. However, viewed in context of the economic, demographic, and societal changes that have occurred over the last fifty years, the growth in government is far less astounding than the sound-bite statistics indicate. For...

Impact of Legislative Decisions on School Funding

State aid to Minnesota school districts—properly adjusted for inflation—has fluctuated significantly over the last fifteen years, but the overall trend has been downward, as documented in a recent North Star report. Of course, long-term trends are not exclusively the...

Minnesota’s Shared Health

Minnesotans value a high quality of life. It is part of the Minnesota story and one of our competitive advantages. This includes having healthy people in healthy communities. Historically, policy makers have recognized the importance of health care access by investing...

Contact Us

Use this form to get in touch with North Star staff, or send your questions, suggestions, and ideas to staff@northstarpolicy.org.