News & Updates

School Vouchers are the Wrong Choice

by | Mar 13, 2017 | Economy, Education, Taxes

Many in the conservative movement advocate for “school choice”: aka educational reform in the way of school vouchers, but there are waves and waves of research that suggest private school vouchers harm students who receive them.

But first: What are school vouchers? The concept originated with Milton Friedman, and is essentially a strategy to privatize schools by subsidizing tuition for private school students (although conservatives will claim it’s about expanding opportunities for low-income students).

The Economic Policy Institute (EPI) described vouchers:

“An educational voucher is a certificate of public funding of a certain amount that can be used by parents of students in any school of the parents’ choosing that accepts such vouchers, usually private.”

The National Education Association estimates that voucher advocates spend about $65 million each year to promote this strategy.

Recently, a plethora of research has come out from comparing voucher students with similar children who took the same standardized tests in public school to see the effect of vouchers. Results from Indiana, Louisiana, and Ohio found that voucher students who transferred to private schools experienced significant losses in achievement, both in math and reading.

Private school vouchers also lack accountability, as most private schools do not have to meet standards for curriculum, testing, teacher qualifications, or school quality, and take money away from neighborhood public schools.

EPI asks a telling question in its recent report on vouchers:

“Why does school privatization at public expense continue to be pushed at the state and federal level when the empirical evidence points so flaringly in one direction – that neither the move from public to private school nor increased competition from private schools significantly improves student achievement?”

The answer, they say, is simple: There is a distinct ideological difference between conservatives, who value individual choice and educational markets – even without results to prove they work – and those who believe in equity and public accountability, supporting public education.

Minnesota should focus on what really matters: equitable achievement for every child, not throwing children into a lottery for a program with no conclusive evidence that it improves student achievement.

Failure is Not an Option

Despite Minnesota having $12.5 billion in one time money and a structural general fund surplus of $6 billion, there is no surplus in transportation funding. This report details decades of declining revenue from dedicated funding sources of transportation...

Underfunded Minnesota: Collective Investment for a Brighter Future

The current budget surplus represents an important opportunity to improve the quality and affordability of life for Minnesotans. For decades, wages have largely stagnated, while workers and families have incurred steeply rising costs for major expenses like childcare,...

Losing Ground: State Disinvestment in Students

Our first report, “Losing Ground”, has a simple but stark finding: over the last twenty years, per pupil state aid received by Minnesota school districts declined by 20 percent, after adjusting for inflation. As state aid has fallen off, school districts have asked...

Contact Us

Use this form to get in touch with North Star staff, or send your questions, suggestions, and ideas to