News & Updates

Catching the Wind: New report examines the impact of local vs. non-local hiring practices on construction of Minnesota wind farms

by | Jun 20, 2018 | Economy, Energy, Infrastructure, Jobs & Wages

A new report published by North Star Policy Institute finds that hundreds of new family-supporting jobs and tens of millions of dollars in economic activity are at stake for Southern Minnesota communities based on imminent hiring decisions by wind energy companies and whether new projects are built by local or non-local workers.

Minnesota’s wind energy economy is booming. The state is eighth in the nation in net generation from wind energy. There are currently at least seven major wind farm projects seeking permits or in pre-construction in Southern Minnesota. These projects will generate an additional 1,400 megawatts in renewable power and add to Minnesota’s already impressive wind energy portfolio.

These seven projects and others in the pipeline have the capacity to create thousands of family-supporting construction jobs. Unfortunately, Southern Minnesota will miss out on many of the economic benefits of new wind farm construction if developers rely primarily on non-local construction workers. Unlike local workers, who spend their wages locally, non-local workers on wind projects typically take the wages they earn back home when they leave.

To better understand the consequences of using local versus non-local workers, the report analyzes the potential economic impact of seven major wind farm projects in Minnesota.

Findings

  • Using 50% to 70% local workers to build 1,400 megawatts of proposed wind generation is projected to generate $73 to $89 million in local economic activity.
  • Using 10% to 30% local workers to build the same wind energy facilities would generate approximately $41 to $57 million in local economic activity.
  • The difference in local economic output of a largely local (50-70%) versus non-local (10-30%) workforce would be approximately $32 million.
  • By including retirement benefits that will be spent down the road by local workers, the potential difference grows by approximately $13 million to $45 million.
  • For a region of the state that has historically lagged the rest of Minnesota in construction job creation and overall economic vitality, this is a particularly concerning loss in economic activity.

Recommendations

The following recommendations would help maximize the local employment and economic benefits of new wind projects.

  • First, to secure specific commitments from developers and engineering, procurement and construction (EPC) contractors to set local hire goals for new wind farm projects during the project approval process.
  • Second, to require regular reporting by developers on their use of local workers.
  • Third, to encourage collaboration with state-registered apprenticeship programs, which can help recruit and train local workers in skills needed to build wind energy facilities.

Through these modest proposals, we can assure efficient use of investments and maximize local benefits.

The full report is available here.

The Misplaced Priorities of “Business” Leaders

Minnesota’s economy is under siege after the first month of a chaotic Trump administration. We’re in an on-again-off-again trade war with our closest neighbors, employers are planning  “recession-level” layoffs, the Executive Branch is unilaterally canceling contracts...

Diverting Dollars: The Danger of School Vouchers in Minnesota

The number of students receiving taxpayer money for vouchers to attend private or religious schools has surged in the US, growing from 12,000 at the turn of the century to over 1 million today. At the same time, evidence has mounted showing that these vouchers weaken...

Progress and Protection: Aligning AI Innovation with Worker Welfare

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is poised to transform the workplace, offering opportunities for innovation while presenting significant challenges for Minnesota’s workers. A recent survey highlights the disconnect between employer expectations and worker experiences:...

Contact Us

Use this form to get in touch with North Star staff, or send your questions, suggestions, and ideas to staff@northstarpolicy.org.