News & Updates

In order to incentivize families to save for their children’s college education, Minnesota and other states are exploring income tax credits and deductions for 529 plans. Named after section 529 of the Internal Revenue Code, these investment vehicles were designed to encourage parents to save for college by granting tax breaks on higher education savings accounts. The track record of these plans in terms of encouraging increased savings, particularly among low income households, is not particularly impressive.

According to 2013 Survey of Consumer Finance (SCF) data compiled by the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (FRS), only one in forty U.S. families that are eligible to take advantage of 529 savings plans actually do so. The extent to which families do take advantage of 529 plans is heavily skewed in favor of higher income households.

Based on SCF data, 16.0 percent of families within the top five percent by income had 529 plans in 2013, compared to 7.9 percent in the 90th to 95th percentile by income, 2.9 percent in the 50 to 90th percentile, and 0.3 percent in the zero to 50th percentile. Furthermore, participation in 529 plans has diminished since 2007 among all groups except the top five percent. Some of this reduction is likely the result of a decline in income during the Great Recession, although the FRS Board of Governors notes that the SCF data is based on a measure of income* that is designed to “circumvent the temporary drop of incomes that many families experienced during the financial crisis.”

Not only is the rate of participation in 529 plans greater among high-income families than among low- and moderate-income families, but the average balance in a 529 account tends to be four times greater among families in the top five percent by income than among other families. The tax advantages associated with current 529 plans likely accrue primarily to high-income households by virtue of the higher participation rate and account balances among high-income households—and as a result of the higher marginal income tax rates paid by high-income households and estate tax planning benefits associated with 529 plans (which will only accrue to a tiny sliver of the wealthiest households subject to the estate tax). The FRS Board of Governors concludes that:

Although 529 plans have increased their presence in the educational-savings space over the past decade, only a very small percentage of families save in these plans, and those who save typically tend to be at the higher end of the income and wealth distributions.

A recent examination of 529’s published by Governing magazine further notes that:

…participation in the [529] plans skewed toward wealthy parents who had college degrees, were already likely to send their children to college, and stood to benefit the most from tax breaks on their investments.

Growth in the cost of attending a public college or university in Minnesota has skyrocketed in recent years, largely due to plummeting state support for public higher education. While the trend of escalating tuition and diminishing state support for higher education is not unique to Minnesota, it has been significantly more pronounced here than in the rest of the nation. These trends have not only created greater barriers to obtaining a higher education—especially among low-income households—but have also contributed to an escalating student debt crisis.

Tax credits and deductions, such as the section 529 credits, are difficult to craft in a way that provide meaningful incentives for low-income households due to their limited income tax liability, whereas restoring past cuts to higher education funding would help all Minnesota students get a quality, affordable education.

 

*This analysis, including the income percentile breakdown in the chart, is based on “usual income,” which is defined by the FRS Board of Governors as follows:

Usual income is designed to capture a version of family income with transitory fluctuations smoothed away in order to approximate the economic concept of “permanent” income. Usual income is measured in the SCF after actual income has been reported, when respondents were given the option to report their usual income if they believe they experienced a temporary deviation.

Big Debt, Big Deal

Minnesota is living under a $27 billion mountain of student loan debt.1 A student graduating in Minnesota today has an average of $31,000 in debt.2 Whether we realize it or not, it is affecting both individuals and the broader community. The challenge of student loan...

Minnesota Business Tax Rate Equals U.S. Average

Business groups—including the Minnesota Business Partnership and Minnesota Chamber of Commerce—actively cultivate the notion that business taxes in the Gopher State are high relative to the rest of the nation. However, total state and local business taxes as a share...

Ensure Respect for Minimum Wage Laws

(Note: This article is co-authored with Laura Huizar, a staff attorney at the National Employment Law Project in Washington, D.C.) A few weeks ago, the St. Paul City Council introduced a draft ordinance that would raise the city’s minimum wage to $15 an hour. That’s a...

Caring in Central Minnesota

Minnesota is getting older every day.1 The aging of our population is increasing demand for home health and personal care workers. We also continue to have population growth through both immigration and natural growth. To fill the needs of our changing population we...

Gas Tax Buys One-Third Less Today Than in 2000

The single largest source of funding for Minnesota’s transportation system comes from the state gas tax. However, the purchasing power of that tax has dropped by over one-third over the course of the century, leaving funding for state roads and bridges in a precarious...

State Aids: The Shrinking Slice of the City Revenue Pie

City property taxes have increased significantly in recent decades. Even after adjusting for inflation and population growth, the property taxes collected by Minnesota cities have increased by 48% from 1990 to 2018. However, real (i.e., inflation-adjusted) per capita...

Government Growth in Context

Shocking claims of growth in government abound. However, viewed in context of the economic, demographic, and societal changes that have occurred over the last fifty years, the growth in government is far less astounding than the sound-bite statistics indicate. For...

Impact of Legislative Decisions on School Funding

State aid to Minnesota school districts—properly adjusted for inflation—has fluctuated significantly over the last fifteen years, but the overall trend has been downward, as documented in a recent North Star report. Of course, long-term trends are not exclusively the...

Minnesota’s Shared Health

Minnesotans value a high quality of life. It is part of the Minnesota story and one of our competitive advantages. This includes having healthy people in healthy communities. Historically, policy makers have recognized the importance of health care access by investing...

Contact Us

Use this form to get in touch with North Star staff, or send your questions, suggestions, and ideas to staff@northstarpolicy.org.